Resistance Band Barbell Squats versus Barbell Squats

Squats are a foundational key when training athletes for sports. The traditional barbell squat builds strength that can later develop into speed and power. It is important to squat to the parallel position to fulfill the full range of muscle movement and to activate additional motor units. To continue to develop strength, athletes must continue to increase the load or weight. When athletes are performing high percentage maximal loads they are susceptible to injury.

            An intelligent alternative to maximal percentage lifts is to combine barbell loads with resistance bands. The value of combining weights with resistance bands not only changes the activation of the muscle but also allows the athlete to descend to the proper depth in the squat without failure. For instance, lets surmise that an athlete has trouble dropping into parallel position with 315lbs on the barbell squat. The athlete has no problem fielding the (parallel) position at 275lbs. With the combination of resistance bands the athlete has less than 315lbs in the parallel position, but through the midpoint and top (depending on the band used) the athlete will yield heavier loads than the 315lb load. A certain win/win in the strength and power world. The assistance of the band helps the athlete get accustomed to heavier loads while still developing strength and avoiding injury.

            The aforementioned training strategy is based on variable resistance versus constant. Variable resistance allows for the change of the resistance during the eccentric (negative) and concentric movement, whereas constant does not vary throughout either of the movements. The two (bands and weights) have been pitted against each other in many trials without necessarily declaring a winner. But the combination of the two methods has proven superior. According to the February 2011 Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research combining weight training with elastic resistance resulted in greater increased absolute strength values during a one-rep-max test compared to a control group using only weights for resistance.


Read more ...